This page is archived

Links to external sources may no longer work as intended. The content may not represent the latest thinking in this area or the Society’s current position on the topic.

Topological avatars of new physics

04 - 05 March 2019 09:00 - 17:00

Scientific Discussion meeting organised by Professor Nikolaos Mavromatos, Dr Laura Patrizii, Dr Vasiliki Mitsou, Professor James Pinfold, Dr Adrian Bevan, Professor Arttu Rajantie and Professor Jonathan Ellis CBE FRS.

The meeting will discuss the theoretical and experimental status of searches for topologically non-trivial solutions in quantum field theories of particle physics, including the Standard Model and its extensions. It will cover both current and future colliders and cosmic searches both on Earth and in space. The topics will include black holes, magnetic monopoles, sphalerons, Q-balls and other solitonic solutions.

The schedule of talks and speaker biographies is available below. Recorded audio of the presentations will be available on this page after the meeting has taken place. 

Enquiries: Contact the Scientific Programmes team.

Organisers

  • KCL Headshots Oct 2014 at the Strand Campus, London on the 01/10/2014. Photo: David Tett

    Professor Nick Mavromatos, King's College London, UK

    Nick E. Mavromatos is a Professor of Theoretical particle Physics at King's College London, Physics Department, a post he holds since September 2006. He graduated (with a Bachelor degree in Physics (BSc) with First class honours in 1984) from the University of Athens (Greece), and obtained a Doctorate degree (D Phil) in theoretical particle physics from Oxford University (UK) in 1987. He has then been a junior research fellow at Hertford College Oxford University (1987-1990), a research fellow at CERN (Switzerland) (1990-1992), a Marie Curie Fellow at Annecy LAPP (1993-1995) and an STFC Advanced Fellow in Oxford (1995- 1999) before moving as a lecturer to the Physics Department of King's College London (1999) and then (2003-2006) a reader. He is a scientific associate at CERN since 1995. His research interests lie on quantum gravity and string theory phenomenology and astro-particle physics. Twice he has been a recipient of the first Award of the Gravity Research Foundation (USA) Essay competition (1999 and 2005). Since 2011 he is the Physics coordinator of the MoEDAL/LHC Experiment at CERN. He is the author of more than 300 research publications and refereed conference proceedings. He is a Fellow of the Institute of Physics (UK) (2004) and an elected ordinary member of the London Physical Society (2003). He has also been several times a visiting professor in the University of Valencia (Spain) where he taught graduate courses on General Relativity and Astroparticle Physics.

  • Dr Adrian Bevan, Queen Mary University of London, UK

    Dr Bevan runs the Particle Physics Research Centre at Queen Mary University of London. After completing his PhD working on the NA48 experiment at CERN, Dr Bevan joined the BaBar experiment at the SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory to search for CP violation in B meson system. He edited a joint BaBar-Belle-Theory effort of 172 scientists to compile a comprehensive record of the Physics of the B Factories. He has since worked on searches for new physics via rare B decays and di-Higgs production on the ATLAS experiment at CERN. He is searching for magnetic monopoles at the MoEDAL experiment at CERN. His current interests include applications of artificial intelligence and machine learning to searches for new particles at the Large Hadron Collider. Dr Bevan is a Fellow of the Institute of Physics, a Turing Fellow and an IPPP associate working on Machine Learning in High Energy Physics.

  • Professor John Ellis CBE FRS, Kings College London, UK

    Jonathan Ellis has made numerous contributions to the theory of elementary particles and especially unified gauge theories. Particularly notable were the first proposal of three jet structure (subsequently seen experimentally) as a gluon signal, and the first precise application of the renormalization group to grand unified theories, with the first precise estimate of sin2 θ W. Works on the theory of CP violation, on the phenomenology of the Higgs boson, and on the implications of grand unified theories for the generation of baryon number in the early Universe, have also attracted much attention. His gift for communication (his summer school lectures and reviews are models of their kind), and his special concern with the experimental implications of topical theories, make him a key figure in the discussion of new high-energy physics projects.

  • Professor Vasiliki Mitsou, IFIC, CSIC - University of Valencia, Spain

    Vasiliki Mitsou (Athens, 1972), a senior scientist at the Institute of Corpuscular Physics of CSIC and the University of Valencia, stands out for contributions to development and data analysis of the ATLAS and MoEDAL experiments at the CERN Large Hadron Collider, searching for New Physics extending the Standard Model currently explaining the Universe at a fundamental level. ATLAS is one of the experiments that discovered the Higgs boson in 2012 leading to the 2013 Nobel Prize in Physics awarded to F. Englert and P. Higgs. She obtained her PhD from the University of Athens in 2002 as a CERN Doctoral Student and held prestigious positions such as a CERN Fellowship and a Ramón y Cajal. She has been awarded the Idea Prize in Basic Science by the City of Arts and Sciences Foundation in 2009 and a Beca Leonadro for Researchers and Cultural Creators by the BBVA Foundation in 2017.

  • Dr Laura Patrizii, Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare, Italy

    Laura Patrizii is Senior Researcher of the Italian Institute for Nuclear Physics. She is active mainly in neutrino physics and magnetic monopole searches. She is a member of the OPERA Collaboration, which recently proved the appearance of tau-neutrinos in the CNGS muon-neutrino beam, and of the DUNE Collaboration set to build and run a long baseline neutrino oscillation experiment for the discovery of the CP violation in the leptonic sector. Laura Patrizii has devoted a large part of her career to the search for magnetic monopoles, both at accelerators and in the cosmic radiation. She is deputy-spokesperson of the MoEDAL experiment aiming at detecting magnetic monopoles produced in LHC high energy collisions. She recently joined the Euclid Consortium. The Euclid mission aims at understanding why the expansion of the Universe is accelerating and what is the nature of the source responsible for this acceleration which physicists refer to as dark energy

  • Professor James Pinfold, University of Alberta, Canada

    While a graduate student, James Pinfold was a leading member of the Gargamelle Experiment team that discovered neutral currents, the first hard evidence for Electroweak Unification. He made key contributions to the development of the Standard Model at Fermilab (USA) and CERN (Switzerland), on the OPAL experiment. On OPAL he pioneered a neural-network based search for the Higgs boson, and contributed to the discovery that there are only three generations of light neutrinos. In 1987, Pinfold became the MODAL experiment’s leader at CERN’s LEP Collider, and led the WA88 experiment at CERN, pioneering new detector technology. A founding member of the ATLAS-LHC experiment, Pinfold made leading contributions to three sub-detectors, early performance studies, and to the Higgs boson’s discovery. From 2000-2010 he was co-spokesperson of the SLIM astroparticle physics experiment atop Bolivia’s Mount Chacaltaya. Currently, Pinfold leads the LHC’s newest experiment, MoEDAL, searching for new physics at the high-energy frontier.

  • Studyshots Education Photography, Photography for University Brochures / Prospectuses, Summer Schools, Lifestyle Photography, Academy Photography, Thomas Angus

    Professor Arttu Rajantie, Imperial College London, UK

    Arttu Rajantie did his PhD in Theoretical Physics at the University of Helsinki, Finland. In 2005, after working at the Universities of Sussex and Cambridge, he moved to Imperial College London where he is Professor of Theoretical Physics. His research deals with non-equilibrium phenomena in quantum field theory and their applications in particle physics and cosmology. He is a member of the MoEDAL collaboration at CERN, which is searching for magnetic monopoles potentially produced in proton-proton and heavy ion collisions at the Large Hadron Collider. In 2015, he was the lead organiser of the Monopole Quest exhibit at the Royal Society Summer Science Exhibition.

Schedule

Chair

KCL Headshots Oct 2014 at the Strand Campus, London on the 01/10/2014. Photo: David Tett

Professor Nick Mavromatos, King's College London, UK

09:00 - 09:20 Welcome by the Royal Society & Professor Nick Mavromatos
09:20 - 09:50 Quantum black holes without chaos

The effects of quantum mechanics on the laws of the gravitational force are difficult to formulate. In the absence of direct experimental information, one must rely on all available knowledge concerning quantum mechanics as well as diffeomorphism invariance, and analyze the questions that arise, as accurately as possible, without using arbitrary assumptions. A most important testing ground is the subject of microscopic black holes. The predictions by standard General Relativity are clear: tiny black holes can grow and shrink by absorbing and emitting particles. Quantum mechanics predicts an evolution law described by a unitary operator. All that is needed here is an operator for tiny or infinitesimal time steps, and this evolution law should be in accordance with the physical laws describing domains of space-time near the horizon. In the lecture, it is claimed that solutions proposed in the literature are wanting in this respect. In particular, these assume that black hole particle emission must be “chaotic”, while it is unreasonable to expect chaos to form during short time stretches. One can do better. The evolution operator is found to be unitary and obey some basic principles of locality. A necessary modification of accepted rules is the so‐called antipodal identification. Another is the identification of Hawking particles emitted by the hole, with the gravitational footprints of all in‐going particles. These observations are used to obtain theories for quantum gravity even in flat backgrounds, in ways often not considered.

Professor Gerard 't Hooft, Institute for Theoretical Physics, Netherlands

10:00 - 10:30 The electroweak monopole: the theory behind it, properties and its relevance in cosmology

The electroweak monopole in the standard model, the existence, characteristic features, cosmological production, and physical implications are discussed. The discovery of Higgs particle has been thought to be the 'final' test of the standard model. If the standard model is correct, however, it must have the electroweak monopole as the electroweak generalization of the Dirac monopole. This means that the detection of this monopole should become the final and topological test of the standard model. If detected, it becomes the first magnetically charged and stable topological elementary particle in the history of physics. Moreover, it has deep implications in physics. In cosmology it could generate the primordial magnetic black holes which could explain the dark matter, become the seed of the large scale structures of the universe, and be the source of the intergalactic magnetic field. As importantly, it could generate the hitherto unknown magnetic current that could have huge practical applications. Furthermore the existence of the monopole requires us to reformulate the perturbative expansion in quantum field theory. This makes the detection of the electroweak monopole a most urgent issue. Useful tips for the MoEDAL detector at LHC and similar experiments to detect the monopole are discussed.

Professor Yongmin Cho, Sogang University, Korea

10:40 - 11:10 Coffee
11:10 - 11:40 Monopole-antimonopole: interactions, scattering and creation

The interaction of a magnetic monopole-antimonopole pair depends on their separation as well as on a second "twist'" degree of freedom. This novel interaction leads to a non-trivial bound state solution known as a sphaleron and to scattering in which the monopole-antimonopole bounce off each other and do not annihilate. The twist degree of freedom also plays a role in numerical experiments in which gauge waves collide and create monopole-antimonopole pairs. Similar gauge wavepacket scatterings in the Abelian-Higgs model lead to the production of string loops that may be relevant to superconductors. Ongoing numerical experiments to study the production of electroweak sphalerons that result in changes in the Chern-Simons number, and hence baryon number, are also described but have not yet met with success.

Professor Tanmay Vachaspati, Arizona State University, USA

11:50 - 12:20 Cosmological evolution of semilocal networks

Semilocal strings are a remarkable example of a stable non-topological defect whose properties resemble those of their topological cousins, the Abrikosov-Nielsen-Olesen vortices. There is, however, one important difference: a network of semilocal strings will contain segments. These are dumbbells whose ends behave almost like global monopoles and are strongly attracted to one another. While closed loops of string will eventually shrink and disappear, the segments can either shrink or grow. We discuss the cosmological formation, evolution and scaling of a network of semilocal strings, its potential signatures and some interesting connections to supersymmetry and particle physics beyond the Standard Model.

Foto: Bram Saeys. Physics@FOM Veldhoven 2015 tuesday 20-1-2015

Professor Ana Achúcarro, Professor Ana Achúcarro, Leiden University, Netherlands and University of the Basque Country, Spain

Chair

Professor Veronica Sanz, University of Sussex, UK

13:30 - 13:55 Machine learning techniques for detecting topological avatars of new physics

The search for highly ionising particles in nuclear track detectors (NTDs) traditionally requires experts to manually search through samples in order to identify regions of interest that could be a hint of physics beyond the Standard Model (SM). The advent of automated image acquisition and modern data science, including machine learning-based processing of data, presents an interesting opportunity to accelerate the process of searching for anomalies in NTDs that could be a hint of a new physics avatar. 

The potential for modern data science to be applied to this topic is discussed, in the context of the MoEDAL experiment at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) at the European Centre for Nuclear Research, CERN. Polymer chains in the NTDs are damaged by ionising particles traversing the plastic. Subsequent chemical etching of the plastic results in nanoscopic damage being transformed into microscopic damage – visible under a microscope or on a modern scanner system. Featuring finding algorithms can be developed, ranging from traditional clustering algorithms to modern deep-learning methods, in order to address the issue of identifying holes in the plastic. A heavily ionising avatar will differ from a SM particle as it will traverse a stack of NTDs inflicting damage to many adjacent foils, whereas the SM particle will range out only affecting a few foils as that particle comes to rest. The potential for modern data science to be applied to this area is explored.

Dr Adrian Bevan, Queen Mary University of London, UK

14:05 - 14:35 The inevitability of sphalerons in field theory

Many field theories have nonlinear equations, but more interesting is when the nonlinearity is geometrically essential, and independent of the details of the theory. This can happen through constraints on the fields, as in sigma models, through the geometry of the vacuum manifold, or through the need to quotient out by gauge transformations. When the Higgs mechanism operates, a nontrivial vacuum manifold and gauge transformations combine. In many such field theories, the field potential energy function inevitably has saddle-points in the infinite-dimensional field configuration space, and these are sphalerons. Sphalerons are smooth, spatially localised solutions of the static field equations, so they are rather like solitons, but unlike solitons they are unstable [ancient Greek: sphaleros = unstable]. Examples of sphalerons are kink-antikink and monopole-antimonopole solutions. Also, the electroweak sector of the Standard Model has no monopoles, but it has sphaleron solutions. The Skyrme model of baryons and nuclei has stable solitons, and also higher energy sphaleron-type solutions. Sphalerons can set the energy scale where perturbation theory breaks down, and control the energy scale for tunnelling, analogous to the transition state controlling a chemical reaction. Tunnelling processes in electroweak theory are accompanied by violations of baryon and lepton number, and could have been important in the early universe.

Professor Nicholas Manton FRS, University of Cambridge, UK

14:45 - 15:15 Tea
15:15 - 15:40 Searches for cosmic magnetic monopoles: past, present and future

In 1931 Dirac introduced the magnetic monopole in order to explain the quantization of the electric charge. Grand Unification Theories (GUT) of the basic interactions imply the existence of monopoles of extremely large mass, O(1016 GeV/c2 ). Larger masses are expected if gravity is brought into the unification picture. Intermediate mass magnetic monopoles (105 – 1012  GeV/c2) are predicted by theories with an intermediate energy scale between the GUT and the electroweak scales and would appear in the early universe at a considerably later time than the GUT epoch. The lowest mass magnetic monopoles should be stable, therefore they should still exist as cosmic relics from the early universe and be a component of the cold dark matter.

Significant efforts have been made over several decades searching for magnetic monopoles whose discovery would represent a breakthrough in particle physics, astrophysics and cosmology. Supermassive poles should have low velocities and relatively large energy losses; they are best searched for underground in the penetrating cosmic radiation. Lower mass monopoles could be relativistic reaching high altitude laboratories.

In this talk the status of the searches for classical, super-heavy, and intermediate mass monopoles with experiments in space, at high altitudes, underground and underwater/ice is reviewed, emphasizing the most recent results and future perspectives.

Dr Laura Patrizii, Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare, Italy

15:50 - 16:15 Monopole-antimonopole pair production by magnetic fields

It is a well-known prediction of quantum electrodynamics that in a strong electric field, electron-positron pairs are produced through the Schwinger process, which can be interpreted as quantum tunnelling through the Coulomb potential barrier. If magnetic monopoles exist, the monopole-antimonopole pairs would be produced by strong magnetic fields through the electromagnetic dual of this process. The production rate can be computed using semiclassical techniques without relying on perturbation theory, and therefore it can be done reliably in spite of monopoles’ strong coupling to the electromagnetic field. This talk explains this process and discusses the bounds on monopole masses arising from the strongest magnetic fields in the universe, which are in neutron stars known as magnetars and in heavy ion collision experiments such as lead-lead collisions carried out in November 2018 in Large Hadron Collider at CERN. The talk will also discuss open theoretical questions affecting the calculation.

Studyshots Education Photography, Photography for University Brochures / Prospectuses, Summer Schools, Lifestyle Photography, Academy Photography, Thomas Angus

Professor Arttu Rajantie, Imperial College London, UK

16:25 - 16:50 The MoEDAL experiment at the LHC - a new light on the high energy frontier

MoEDAL is a pioneering LHC experiment designed to search for anomalously ionizing messengers of new physics such as magnetic monopoles or massive (pseudo-)stable charged particles, which are predicted to existing in a plethora of models beyond the Standard Model. It started data taking at the LHC at a centre-of-mass energy of 13 TeV in 2015. Its ground breaking physics program defines a number of scenarios that yield potentially revolutionary insights into such foundational questions as: are there extra dimensions or new symmetries; what is the mechanism for the generation of mass; does magnetic charge exist; and what is the nature of dark matter. MoEDAL's purpose is to meet such far-reaching challenges at the frontier of the field. We will present the results from the MoEDAL detector on Magnetic Monopole and highly ionizing electrically charged particle production that are the world’s best. In conclusion, progress on the installation of MoEDAL’s MAPP (MoEDAL Apparatus for the detection of Penetrating Particles) sub-detector prototype will be very briefly be discussed.

Professor James Pinfold, University of Alberta, Canada

17:15 - 18:15 Poster Session

Chair

Professor Vasiliki Mitsou, IFIC, CSIC - University of Valencia, Spain

09:00 - 09:30 Prospects for High Energy Physics, including searches for highly ionising particles in current and future colliders

This contribution will discuss briefly the status of present searches for new particles at the high energy frontier, as conducted at the LHC. It will then introduce ideas of potentially new experiments to search for long lived highly ionising topological avatars, as well as so called hidden particles. The discovery of such new particles would lead to major advancements and the deeper understanding of particle physics beyond the Standard Model, and directly address present open questions such as dark matter, the matter asymmetry in the universe and others. New experiments for long lived particles at the LHC comprise the MilliQan, the Codex-b, the MATHUSLA, the FASER and the AL3X experiments. Some of these experimental ideas are also explored for planning future beam-dump experiments e.g. at neutrino experiment near detectors and for the proposal of the CERN/SHiP experiment. The potential for searches for such particles at future new colliders is also briefly discussed.

Professor Albert De Roeck, CERN, Switzerland

09:40 - 10:10 Monopoles in the standard model

Two things will be explained in this talk. First, that there is an ambiguity in the gauge group of the Standard Model, and this affects the possible monopoles that may be observed in the future. Second, that there is an unsolved problem in how to define magnetically charged particles in gauge theories with chiral matter.

Professor David Tong, University of Cambridge, UK

10:20 - 10:45 Coffee
10:45 - 11:15 Baryon number violating scatterings in the laboratory

Although it is well known that baryon number violating processes happen in the electroweak theory, there is a large (about 70 orders of magnitude) discrepancy in the determination of the baryon number violating scattering cross-sections at energies around the sphaleron energy of 9 TeV, separating the potentially observable from the totally unobservable predictions in the laboratory.

The (old) pessimistic estimate is unreliable as the energy approaches the sphaleron energy, so it is useful to take an entirely different approach to this problem. The more optimistic estimate is based on the Bloch wave approach, which reliably covers energies ranging from zero to the sphaleron energy and above. At low energies, both studies yield an exponentially small cross-section, but the Bloch wave approach yields a much bigger rate as the energy approaches the sphaleron energy. Recently, this idealized Bloch wave approach is further improved by taking into account the presence of the baryon number conserving direction as well as the fermion masses, a much more realistic situation.

At the present proton-proton energy of 14 TeV at the LHC, the parton distribution and phase space suppression is quite severe. Orders of magnitude in the event rate can be gained if LHC can double its present energy.

Professor S H Henry Tye, Cornell University, USA

11:25 - 11:55 Baryon number violating processes in particle collisions at very high energies

Conservation of baryon number is one of the fundamental laws which has been verified with a great accuracy. However, existence of baryon number violating processes is predicted within the Standard Model of particle physics. These processes are related to the transitions between topologically nonequivalent vacua which are separated by a potential barrier. The probability of these processes is known to be exponentially suppressed at small energies but grows with the energy increase. This talk discusses a semiclassical method to calculate the probability of the baryon number violating processes induced by collisions of a few particles. The method is argued to be valid at all collision energies and improved numerical calculations confirm that the probability of baryon number violating processes stay exponentially suppressed even at the energies much larger than the barrier height. Possible applications to extensions of the Standard Model are discussed.

Professor Sergei Demidov, Institute for Nuclear Research of Russian Academy of Sciences, Russia

12:00 - 12:25 Searching for supersymmetry

Supersymmetry is one of the most interesting scenarios for physics beyond the Standard Model. It could help us understand the scale of the weak interactions and the mass of the Higgs boson, it would help unify the fundamental interactions, and it could provide the dark matter expected by astrophysicists and cosmologists. Supersymmetry predicts the existence of many new particles. None has yet been discovered, but it is possible that there might exist a long-lived supersymmetric particle that could be detected by the MoEDAL experiment at the Large Hadron Collider.

Professor John Ellis CBE FRS, King’s College London, UK

Chair

Professor Mairi Sakellariadou, King's College London, UK

13:35 - 14:05 Black holes in the quantum universe

In general relativity, black holes furnish classic examples of spacetime topology - as well as predicting its breakdown. But nature is quantum-mechanical, and this appears to force a different view of black holes and of spacetime itself. This talk will sketch some basic elements of proposals for this structure and for black hole evolution that is consistent with quantum mechanics.

Professor Steven Giddings, University of California, Santa Barbara and CERN, USA

14:15 - 14:45 Primordial black holes as dark matter and their detection with gravitational waves

More than twenty-two years ago, we predicted that massive primordial black holes (PBH) would form via the gravitational collapse of radiation and matter associated with high peaks in the spectrum of curvature fluctuations, and that they could constitute all of the dark matter today. In 2015, we predicted the clustering and broad mass distribution of PBH, which peaks at several Msun, and whose high-mass tails could be responsible for the seeds of all galaxies. Since then, LIGO has detected gravitational waves from ten merger events of very massive black hole binaries. We propose that they are PBH, and predict that within a few years a less than one solar mass PBH will be detected by AdvLIGO-VIRGO, and that in 10 years, an array of GW detectors (i.e. LIGO, VIRGO, KAGRA, INDIGO, etc.) could be used to determine the mass and spin distribution of PBH dark matter with 10% accuracy. Thus, gravitational wave astronomy could be responsible for a new paradigm shift in the understanding of the nature of dark matter and the evolution of the large scale structures in the universe.

DVD157-(15/07/05). Juan García Bellido, experto en métodos matemáticos, gravitación y cosmología. © Luis Magán.

Professor Juan Garcia-Bellido, Universidad Autonoma de Madrid, Spain

14:55 - 15:20 Tea
15:20 - 15:50 Black hole dark matter

Professor Marc Kamionkowski, Johns Hopkins University, USA

16:00 - 17:00 Panel discussion/overview

Professor Annarita Margiotta, University of Bologna, Italy

Professor John Ellis CBE FRS, King’s College London, UK

Professor Albert De Roeck, CERN, Switzerland

Professor Steven Giddings, University of California, Santa Barbara and CERN, USA

Professor Marc Kamionkowski, Johns Hopkins University, USA

Professor Vasiliki Mitsou, IFIC, CSIC - University of Valencia, Spain

Professor James Pinfold, University of Alberta, Canada

Professor Mairi Sakellariadou, King's College London, UK

Professor Veronica Sanz, University of Sussex, UK

Professor Tanmay Vachaspati, Arizona State University, USA