Tissue resilience in health and disease

26 - 27 April 2023 09:00 - 17:00 INNSiDE Manchester Free
Wound inflammatory response

Theo Murphy international scientific meeting organised by Dr Helen Weavers and Professor Anna Jazwinska.

Most animal and plant tissues have an intrinsic ability to withstand day-to-day stress, but many also exhibit extraordinary adaptive responses to stress that drive increased ‘resilience’ against further insult. This inter-disciplinary meeting showcased cutting-edge research from basic scientists and clinicians exploring the mechanistic basis and translational potential of these remarkable phenomena, including the role of diet, ageing and biomechanics.

Meeting papers will be available in a future issue of Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B.  

Attending this event

This meeting has taken place. 

Enquiries: contact the Scientific Programmes team.

Kidney tubule. Image credit: Jack Holcombe 

Image: Jack Holcombe (Kidney tubule)

Zebrafish heart (Anna Jazwinska Lab)

Image: Zebrafish heart (Anna Jazwinska Lab)

Organisers

  • Helen Weavers

    Dr Helen Weavers, Biomedical Sciences, Bristol, UK

    Helen Weavers is a Wellcome Trust and Royal Society Sir Henry Dale Fellow at the University of Bristol. She obtained her PhD from the University of Cambridge in 2012 and held a short post-doctoral position at the University of Bristol (2013-2017) before starting her own lab in 2018. Much of Helen’s research is driven by understanding how body tissues (such as the skin or renal system) resist and recover from insult. In particular, she studies the molecular and cellular mechanisms that make tissues resilient to damage caused by toxic molecules or physical injury. 

  • Anna J

    Professor Anna Jazwinska, the University of Fribourg, Switzerland

    Anna Jazwinska is full professor at the University of Fribourg in Switzerland. She obtained her PhD from the University of Cologne in Germany in 2000. She held a post-doctoral position at the Biozentrum in Basel in Switzerland (2000-2004). Then, she was an instructor and associate researcher at the Harvard Medical School and Children’s Hospital Boston, USA. She started her own lab at the University of Fribourg in 2007. Her current research focuses on organ regeneration and cardiac preconditioning in zebrafish.

Schedule

Chair

Helen Weavers

Dr Helen Weavers, Biomedical Sciences, Bristol, UK

09:00-09:05 Welcome by the lead organiser
09:05-09:30 Synaptic and metabolic targets for ischemic neuroprotection by preconditioning paradigms

Synaptic dysfunction has been linked to cognitive impairments after cerebral ischemia. The mechanisms underlying ischemia-induced synaptic dysfunction and cognitive impairments have not been fully elucidated. Although many mechanisms have been postulated, metabolic derangements have also been implicated since vascular and mitochondrial dysfunction also developed following cerebral ischemia.

Professor Perez-Pinzon's laboratory focuses on investigating the phenomenon of ischemic preconditioning, which involves exposing the brain to a sub-lethal ischemic insult prior to a lethal one, resulting in increased tissue resilience. The author of the talk with a group of researchers have identified key mimetic molecules that mimic the synaptic and metabolic resilience observed following ischemic preconditioning.

This presentation highlights the research group's findings on the signalling pathways that promote metabolic, synaptic, and cognitive improvements following cerebral ischemia. The results have important implications for the development of novel therapeutic strategies for ischemic brain injury.

Professor Miguel Perez-Pinzon, University of Miami, USA

Professor Miguel Perez-Pinzon, University of Miami, USA

09:30-09:40 Discussion
09:40-10:10 Macrophage control of tissue homeostasis

Tissue homeostasis relies on a network of cell intrinsic and extrinsic mechanisms that maintain vital variables within a dynamic range compatible with maintenance of organismal fitness and survival. These homeostatic processes involve an active interplay between cell proliferation, differentiation, and death. Macrophages are tissue-resident innate immune cells that act, beyond microbial sensing and clearance, to support tissue homeostasis. Here the scientists adapted a stable two-cell system in vitro1, based on the interplay between macrophages and fibroblasts, which recapitulates tissue homeostasis in vivo. They found that disruption of iron metabolism, imposed by the deletion of the heavy chain of ferritin (FTH), compromised regulation of homeostasis in the two-cell system in vitro as well as in mice. FTH-expressing macrophages re-established homeostatic control in the stable two-cell system in vitro as well as in vivo, restoring organismal energy metabolism and survival of Fth-deleted mice. RNAseq analysis of rescuing macrophages revealed the induction of an array of mitochondrial genes, not expressed in Fth-deficient macrophages, suggesting that macrophages restore homeostasis in Fth-deleted mice via a mechanism associated with mitochondrial biogenesis and arguably mediated via mitochondria transfer to stressed tissues. Their findings effectively validate the stable two-cell system as an in vitro model system to study regulation of tissue homeostasis by macrophages in vivo

1. Zhou, X. et al. Circuit Design Features of a Stable Two-Cell System. Cell 172, 744-757 e717 (2018).

Dr Rui Martins, Instituto Gulbenkian de Ciência, Portugal

Dr Rui Martins, Instituto Gulbenkian de Ciência, Portugal

10:10-10:20 Discussion
10:20-10:50 Break
10:50-11:20 Hormesis and the limits of biological plasticity: biological and clinical implications

Phenotypic plasticity represents an environmentally-based change in an organism’s observable properties. It has been evaluated for its quantitative features and genetic basis, especially within an ecological-evolutionary framework. Toxicological experiments on the dose-response continuum over a wide dose range provide evidence that the hormetic dose response zone offers a quantitative estimate of phenotypic plasticity. The low dose hormetic stimulation is an adaptive response that is an environmental-induced altered phenotype and provides a quantitative estimate of biological plasticity. The magnitude of phenotype changes indicative of plasticity is modest with maximum responses about 30-60% greater than control values. These findings represent the first quantitative estimates of biological plasticity along with broad generalization from bacteria to humans. According to the hormesis-plasticity perspective such increases are bounded by the limits of biological plasticity which are defined by the quantitative features of the hormetic dose response. This analysis establishes the upper limits of chemical and pharmacological agents to upregulate biological performance (e.g., cognitive enhancement, hair growth, disease resistance) and should drive the design of experimental and clinical investigations, with respect to the number of doses, and dose spacing, and guide their capacity to detect significant treatment effects in epidemiological studies, including the randomized clinical trial (RCT).

Professor Edward J. Calabrese, University of Massachusetts, School of Public Health and Health Sciences, Amherst, USA

Professor Edward J. Calabrese, University of Massachusetts, School of Public Health and Health Sciences, Amherst, USA

11:20-11:30 Discussion
11:30-12:00 NRF2/ARE signalling in tissue homeostasis and stress resistance: from circadian regulation to extracellular matrix organisation

Abstract of the talk will be available soon.

Dr Vanja Pekovic-Vaughan, University of Liverpool, UK

Dr Vanja Pekovic-Vaughan, University of Liverpool, UK

12:00-12:10 Discussion
12:10-12:30 Plants take their time in fluctuating environments

Dr Dora Cano-Ramirez's research focuses on understanding how plants respond and adapt to fluctuating environments. Recently Dr Cano-Ramirez together with a group of researchers identified a mechanism that plants use to cope with cold bright mornings when their photosynthetic machinery is at its most vulnerable.

Plants need to be able to discern when to take low temperature seriously. During winter and spring, the coldest time of day is usually just before dawn, when the earth has lost the maximum amount of heat energy from the previous short day’s sun. This will trigger cold acclimation mechanisms that gradually adapt plants to freezing temperatures. Light combined with low temperatures can be very dangerous to a plant and the researchers found that plants have employed an evolutionarily-ancient mechanism in the chloroplasts to help them tolerate the cold. Low temperatures and circadian signals are integrated by a sigma factor, which contributes to protection of photosynthesis before and during freezing. The scientists found that the plant’s circadian clock helps them make the decision to respond, based on the time of day the cold snap happens. This suggests the pathway is of considerable biological importance in plants and could be targeted to improve crop yields under uncertain climate conditions.

Currently Dr Cano-Ramirez is looking at the stochastic nature, or randomness, of transcription factors and gene expression in plants growing under variable environmental stresses.

Dr Dora Cano-Ramirez, Sainsbury Laboratory, University of Cambridge, UK

Dr Dora Cano-Ramirez, Sainsbury Laboratory, University of Cambridge, UK

12:30-11:40 Discussion
12:40-13:50 Lunch

Chair

Anna J

Professor Anna Jazwinska, the University of Fribourg, Switzerland

13:50-14:20 Injury and repair in kidney transplantation

Kidney transplantation is a the best treatment of end stage kidney disease. However shortage of donor organs necessitates the utilisation of kidneys from higher risk donors, older with additional morbidities. Deceased kidney donation is the main source of transplants, yet these grafts yield inferior short and long- term transplant outcomes when compared to living donation. Dr Maria Kaisar's work focuses in identifying molecular signatures of subclinical kidney injury and tissue resilience. 

Analysis of clinical samples obtained from the Quality in Organ Donation (QUOD) Biobank by high end mass spectrometry technologies shown the impact of cytoskeletal protein degradation in dysregulating the kidney cytoskeleton in donor kidneys with suboptimal transplant function. Dr Kaisar's lab has described the role of interaction of TGFβ and Calpain-1 axis in proteolytic processing of Talin-1 and Actinin-4 in kidney cytoskeleton (Vaughan et al., AJT 2019). Dr Kaisar's current studies focus on the impact of donor age and circulatory inflammation in the progression of proteolytic activation and kidney injury. 

Mass spectrometry analysis of kidney biopsies and integration of molecular signatures with clinical data using machine learning has revealed that we can achieve granularity in donor kidney assessment stratification and better understanding of the biological alterations that lead to kidney injury progression. Dr Maria Kaisar's lab has identified age-modulated immuno-metabolic proteome profiles of deceased donor kidneys predict 12-month posttransplant outcome (Charles P et al., https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2023.03.31.23288011v1) 

Their current investigations aim to study the role of aging and inflammation in proteolytic degradation of kidney cytoskeletons and develop better assessment tools of donor organ quality. Studying the mechanisms of donor kidney injury and resilience will lead them to develop novel interventions to recondition donor organs and improve transplant outcomes.  

 
Dr Maria Kaisar, University of Oxford

Dr Maria Kaisar, University of Oxford

14:20-14:30 Discussion
14:30-15:00 Mechanisms of longevity: lessons from the naked mole rat

Professor Gorbunova's talk will form on the mechanisms of longevity in the naked mole rat and on strategies of translating it to other species including humans.

Professor Vera Gorbunova, University of Rochester, USA

Professor Vera Gorbunova, University of Rochester, USA

15:00-15:10 Discussion
15:10-15:40 Break
15:40-16:10 Title of the talk will be available soon.

Abstract of the talk will be available soon.

Professor Ellie Tzima, University of Oxford, UK

Professor Ellie Tzima, University of Oxford, UK

16:10-16:20 Discussion
16:20-16:50 Stress signaling in C. elegans: how the nervous system links environmental perception with tissue resilience and healthy ageing

Detecting and responding to environmental stress is crucial to the survival of organisms. The Taylor lab studies the ways in which stress detection by the nervous system leads to the activation of organism-wide defence mechanisms that can increase tissue resilience and slow down the ageing process. In particular, the scientists are interested in the unfolded protein response of the endoplasmic reticulum (UPRER), and its activation in downstream tissues following signalling by neurons. Through studying the transcriptome of different cell types in C. elegans following genetic activation of the UPRER, they have uncovered mechanisms by which UPRER activation in the nervous system triggers the sending of UPRER-activating signals to the intestinal cells of the animal, and have also revealed the ability of neuronal stress response activation to alter the behaviour of the worm in ways that are appropriate to stressful environments. In addition, the scientists have identified a novel ability of intestinal UPRER activation to enhance the acidity and activity of lysosomes, leading to improved protein and metabolic homeostasis and resulting in delayed ageing and extended longevity. Finally, they have pinpointed specific environmental cues that trigger UPRER-activating neuronal signalling. Their analyses have therefore revealed novel mechanisms by which multicellular organisms orchestrate resilience in the face of stress, utilizing neuronal signalling systems to coordinate multiple responses across different tissues of the animal.

Dr Rebecca Taylor, University of East Anglia, UK

Dr Rebecca Taylor, University of East Anglia, UK

16:50-17:00 Discussion
17:00-18:15 Poster session / flash talks
09:00-09:30 Ischemic ‘conditioning’ as a therapeutic tool to increase tissue resilience: trials, tribulations and clinical translation

Overwhelming preclinical evidence has revealed that brief and transient episodes of non-lethal ischemia paradoxically render tissues resistant to a subsequent, more sustained ischemic insult. This phenomenon, termed ‘ischemic conditioning’, was first described in the heart and has subsequently been reported in other organs susceptible to ischemia- and ischemia-reperfusion injury, including (but not limited to) the brain, liver and kidney. Progress has been made in elucidating the molecular mechanisms that contribute to conditioning-induced tissue protection in cardiac models. In addition, results from initial Phase II clinical trials suggested that ischemic conditioning may improve outcomes following both planned and unplanned ischemic event (ie, cardiac surgery and ST segment elevation acute myocardial infarction, respectively). In contrast, subsequent large Phase III trials have failed to confirm significant clinical benefit. Future successful clinical translation of ischemic conditioning will require a re-evaluation of the relevance and rigor of the preclinical models that have been used, together with an enhanced understanding of the factor(s) that favour versus preclude the development of a ‘conditioned’ phenotype.

Professor Karin Przyklenk, Children's Hospital of Michigan/Central Michigan University, USA

Professor Karin Przyklenk, Children's Hospital of Michigan/Central Michigan University, USA

09:30-09:40 Discussion
09:40-10:10 Cardio-resilience due to chronic or brief stresses: pathology vs conditioning

The response of the adult human myocardium to a relatively long sustained injurious insult (eg, during cardiac surgery) can be altered by pathology. The progression of different cardiac diseases triggers different remodelling (metabolic, molecular, structural etc) that determine how the heart responds to the insult and the extent of injury. Additionally, brief non-injurious stresses applied directly to the heart (conditioning) are known to protect the myocardium against a long sustained injurious insult. The conditioning can also be a remote one (Remote Ischaemic Preconditioning, RIPC) where a brief stress applied to a distant organ is cardioprotective. RIPC has advantages but its clinical translation in disease setting has been controversial. Understanding of disease-induced cardiac remodelling and mechanisms underlying conditioning is important for mobilising cardiac intrinsic protective pathways.

Professor M.-Saadeh Suleiman, Bristol Medical School, Bristol University, UK

Professor M.-Saadeh Suleiman, Bristol Medical School, Bristol University, UK

10:10-10:20 Discussion
10:20-11:00 Break
11:00-11:30 Cardioprotection by remote ischemic conditioning (RIC) and its translation

There is still a medical need for cardioprotection beyond that by rapid coronary reperfusion, since mortality and morbidity, notably from heart failure, in patients with acute myocardial infarction remain high. Brief cycles of ischemia/reperfusion in a tissue or organ remote from the heart (RIC) reduce infarct size from sustained myocardial ischemia/reperfusion in all species tested so far, including humans. In the researchers' pig model of reperfused acute myocardial infarction, RIC before (preconditioning) or during (perconditioning) coronary occlusion reduces infarct size. The signal transfer of RIC from the periphery to the heart involves humoral and neuronal factors. Humoral factors of RIC can be transferred with plasma preparations from one individual to another, even across species. The neuronal signal transfer involves peripheral sensory afferents, the central nervous system and vagal efferents. The spleen serves as a decisive relay organ of RIC and releases humoral cardioprotective factors upon vagal activation. The protective signal transduction in the myocardium involves STAT3 activation and improved mitochondrial function. Repeated blood pressure cuff inflation/deflation on the arm or leg has been demonstrated to reduced infarct size and improve clinical outcome in patients undergoing coronary bypass surgery when this RIC was used in a preconditioning mode and in patients with reperfused acute myocardial infarction when RIC was used in a perconditioning mode. However, larger clinical trials with neutral results on RIC also exist and have raised disappointment on its translation. Co-morbidities, co-medications but also a primordial myocardial non-responsiveness may interfere with cardioprotection by RIC. It appears important to focus on RIC in patients who really need adjunct cardioprotection because they are at high risk and/or have suboptimal therapeutic reperfusion, and respective trials are underway. Humoral factors of RIC in humans can also be transferred to bioassay recipient hearts. In cardiosurgical patients, the myocardial signal tranduction of RIC also involves STAT activation and improved mitochondrial function. 

Nat Rev Cardiol 12,2020,773-89; Basic Res Cardiol 117,2022,39 and 58; AJP 323,2022,H 1365-75

Professor Gerd Heusch, Institute for Pathophysiology, West German Heart and Vascular Centre, University Duisburg-Essen/Germany

Professor Gerd Heusch, Institute for Pathophysiology, West German Heart and Vascular Centre, University Duisburg-Essen/Germany

11:30-11:40 Discussion
11:40-12:10 SUMO Cell Atlas

Post-translational modification (PTM) events generate proteoforms that orchestrate cell signalling in almost every biological process. The SUMOcode project aims to understand a critically important but understudied PTM in plants, SUMO (Small Ubiquitin-like Modifier). The rules governing specificity and function remain rudimentary for most PTMs, but the plant SUMO system provides a unique possibility to unravel the rules governing SUMOylation, as its core machinery comprises only 33 genes in Arabidopsis, compared with many hundreds for other PTMs.

Professor Sadanandom's central hypothesis is that SUMO specificity is conferred through how cells are primed to respond to different stress signals, the tissue and cellular spatial distribution of SUMO machinery and substrates and control of SUMOylation modification via activation, repression and competition for PTM sites.

Professor Sadanandom with a group of researchers have developed a SUMO system cell atlas (a resource that will characterize each part of the machinery), how and in which cells and when it works, so that a map of the key events that trigger a SUMOylation response to environmental cues can be revealed. They will use the model plant, Arabidopsis, arguably the best non-human, multicellular organism for this scale of interrogation. It has a plethora of tools and resources that will allow us to dissect the SUMO code in detail and across different cell types, different stages of development and across different response times. This mapping of SUMOylation will reveal the ‘hubs’ that the SUMO machinery targets to cause a cellular response, revealing how the pathway functions and how it can be manipulated to combat environmental challenges or disease. 

Professor Ari Sadanandom, Durham University, UK

Professor Ari Sadanandom, Durham University, UK

12:10-12:20 Discussion
12:30-13:30 Lunch
13:30-14:00 Resilience, healthy ageing and longevity: a biological perspective

More than 60 years of biogerontological research has led to the understanding that ageing is not a disease, and there are no ageing-causing gerontogenes. Genes determine our ability to survive and maintain health for a limited period, known as the essential lifespan of the species. These longevity-assurance genes or vitagenes create a homeodynamic space, characterised by stress response, damage control and constant remodelling. Resilience, robustness and longevity of an organism are the primary expressions of the homeodynamic space. We are, of course, able to live much longer than our species’ essential lifespan, but our imperfect homeodynamic space progressive shrinks due to the accumulation of molecular damage, and makes us less robust, less resilient and more prone to physical impairment and consequent diseases. Among various interventional approaches being tested and developed, an evidence-based holistic scientific strategy towards healthy ageing is that of mild stress-induced hormesis. Physical, nutritional and mental stress-inducing hormetins lead to the strengthening of the homeodynamics of maintenance and repair systems. Exercise, heat and irradiation are examples of physical hormetins, which activate various stress responses. Several non-nutritional chemical components in the food, such as flavonoids and polyphenols present in spices, herbs and other sources, are examples of nutritional hormetins. Calorie restriction and intermittent fasting are hormetins, which activate the autophagic and sirtuin-mediated stress responses. Intense brain activity and focused attention comprise mental hormetins. A combination of different hormetins offers the possibility of recovering and enhancing body’s resilience and robustness, and help achieving healthy ageing and longer lifespans.

Professor Suresh Rattan, Aarhus University, Denmark

Professor Suresh Rattan, Aarhus University, Denmark

14:00-14:15 Discussion
14:15-14:45 The role of metabolic resilience in healthy ageing

Energy metabolism provides fuel for basic and adaptive activities of the cell including quality control and repair processes. Moreover, metabolic plasticity is directly required for the successful adaptation of the cells to extrinsic and intrinsic stressors, and it supports the healthy longevity at the organismal level. In previous work, the authors of this study found that the adaptive capacities of mitochondria, lipid metabolism and glycolysis fail with age in an interconnected fashion. This failure has an impact not only on the general well-being of the organism but also on the positive effects of the resilience-promoting treatments such as dietary restriction (DR) and DR-mimetic compounds like metformin. Particularly, the scientists found that resilience benefits of metformin in non-diabetic C. elegans are abrogated and even reversed following late-life onset intervention, with life extension of metformin-exposed young nematodes mirrored by toxicity of this drug in old animals and cells. In this talk Dr Maria Ermolaeva will discuss molecular mechanisms that underlay late life failures of the conventional metabolic resilience treatments, and will speak about new intervention paradigms discovered by her group, which facilitate metabolic plasticity independently of age.  

Dr Maria Ermolaeva, Leibniz Institute on Aging  – Fritz Lipmann Institute (FLI), Germany

Dr Maria Ermolaeva, Leibniz Institute on Aging – Fritz Lipmann Institute (FLI), Germany

14:45-15:00 Discussion
15:00-15:30 Break
15:30-16:00 Hidden costs of dietary restriction in the fly

Dietary restriction (DR) extends lifespan and healthspan reliably and strongly across model organisms. Potential costs of DR have been proposed however. Dr Simons together with a group of scientists showed recently using meta-analysis in mice that costs of DR on immunity are probable, and they recently confirmed this experimentally in the fly. They further showed that DR makes flies vulnerable to refeeding syndrome, contrary to current predictions from evolutionary theory. Dr Simons will interpret these results using recent theoretical process they have made in understanding DR on the theoretical level using a reaction norm framework and reliability theory of ageing.

Dr Mirre Simons, University of Sheffield, UK

Dr Mirre Simons, University of Sheffield, UK

16:00-16:15 Discussion
16:15-17:00 Panel discussion/overview

Short talks at the start of the section:

Professor Anna Jazwinska - Cardiac preconditioning in zebrafish

Dr Helen Weavers - Tissue resilience takes flight

Professor Anna Jazwinska, the University of Fribourg, Switzerland

Professor Anna Jazwinska, the University of Fribourg, Switzerland

Dr Helen Weavers, Biomedical Sciences, Bristol, UK

Dr Helen Weavers, Biomedical Sciences, Bristol, UK